absurdtools

Water Purification Method Comparison

Which treatment actually covers what — filters miss viruses, iodine misses Cryptosporidium, and boiling covers everything. The gaps are the point.

What are you worried about?

Viruses are unchecked by default because they are rarely the concern in North American and European backcountry. Tick them for anywhere water may carry human sewage — which includes much of the world.

The full matrix

Method BacteriaVirusesProtozoaCryptosporidium Time
Boiling ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ One minute at a rolling boil, or three minutes above 6,500 ft (2,000 m) where water boils cooler.
Filter (0.2 micron) ✅ ❌ ✅ ✅ Immediate — you drink as you pump or squeeze.
Purifier (0.02 micron or filter plus chemical) ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ Immediate, or as long as the chemical stage requires.
Chlorine dioxide tablets or drops ✅ ✅ ✅ 🕐 30 minutes for bacteria and viruses — but four hours for Cryptosporidium.
Iodine tablets ✅ ✅ ✅ ❌ 30 minutes, longer in cold or cloudy water.
UV pen ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ About 90 seconds per litre.

✅ effective · 🕐 effective but slowly · ❌ not reliable

Method by method

Boiling

Time: One minute at a rolling boil, or three minutes above 6,500 ft (2,000 m) where water boils cooler.

Weight: No extra gear, but it costs fuel and time, and you have to wait for it to cool.

The only method that handles everything with no exceptions. It does nothing about chemicals, silt or taste.

Filter (0.2 micron)

Time: Immediate — you drink as you pump or squeeze.

Weight: Two to twelve ounces depending on style. Squeeze filters are the light option.

Viruses are far smaller than the pore size and pass straight through. That is acceptable in most North American and European backcountry, and not acceptable where water may carry human sewage.

Purifier (0.02 micron or filter plus chemical)

Time: Immediate, or as long as the chemical stage requires.

Weight: Heavier and slower-flowing than a plain filter.

The distinction between "filter" and "purifier" is a real one, not marketing: a purifier is rated for viruses and a filter is not.

Chlorine dioxide tablets or drops

Time: 30 minutes for bacteria and viruses — but four hours for Cryptosporidium.

Weight: Almost nothing. The standard lightweight backup.

That four-hour figure is the one people skip. If Cryptosporidium is a real risk, thirty minutes is not treatment, and dosing at dinner for the next morning is the practical answer.

Iodine tablets

Time: 30 minutes, longer in cold or cloudy water.

Weight: Negligible, and cheap.

Iodine does not reliably kill Cryptosporidium at any practical field dose or contact time. It also tastes strongly, stains, and is not for long-term use, pregnancy, or people with thyroid conditions.

UV pen

Time: About 90 seconds per litre.

Weight: Around five ounces with batteries.

Needs water that is genuinely clear — silt and tannin shadow the organisms from the light. Pre-filter cloudy water, and remember it depends on batteries and an intact lamp.

The two gaps worth memorising

Filters do not remove viruses. A 0.2 micron filter physically strains out bacteria and protozoa, but viruses are one to two orders of magnitude smaller and pass straight through. This is fine in remote backcountry where the water has not passed through a human population, and it is not fine in a great deal of the world. The distinction between a "filter" and a "purifier" is real and not marketing: a purifier is rated for viruses.

Cryptosporidium shrugs off halogens. Its oocysts have a tough outer wall, so iodine does not reliably kill it at any practical field dose, and chlorine dioxide needs about four hours rather than the thirty minutes on the packet. The practical answer is to dose at dinner for the next morning — or to filter, since a 0.2 micron filter removes it mechanically without needing to kill it at all.

This is general information rather than medical advice, and treatment guidance changes. For international travel or any specific health condition, check current advice from a public-health authority rather than a web page.

How to use

  1. Work out what is likely in your water source.
  2. Match the treatment to the organisms it actually covers.
  3. Follow the contact time, not just the dose.
  4. Combine methods where one alone leaves a gap.

Frequently asked questions

What does a filter miss?

Viruses. Common backcountry filters run around 0.1 to 0.2 microns, which reliably removes bacteria and protozoa including Giardia and Cryptosporidium, but viruses are smaller and pass straight through. In much of North America's backcountry that risk is low; in areas with human contamination, or in much of the developing world, it is not.

What does iodine miss?

Cryptosporidium, which has a tough shell that resists iodine and chlorine at field doses and realistic contact times. This is the most important gap in chemical treatment, and it matters because Cryptosporidium is common in water contaminated by livestock or human waste.

What covers everything?

Boiling. Bringing water to a rolling boil kills bacteria, viruses and protozoa including Cryptosporidium — reaching the temperature does the work, so the time at a full boil need only be brief, with a longer hold commonly advised at high altitude. It costs fuel and time, which is the only reason not to.

What about chlorine dioxide?

It does cover Cryptosporidium, unlike iodine and ordinary chlorine, but it needs a long contact time to do so — often four hours, against the 30 minutes on the label for everything else. Treating and drinking after half an hour leaves that gap open, which people routinely do without realising.

Should I combine methods?

Where the gaps matter, yes. Filtering then treating chemically covers protozoa by the filter and viruses by the chemical, which is the standard approach in areas where both are a concern. UV treatment covers all three but needs clear water and working batteries, so it is often paired with a pre-filter.

Is clear-looking water safe?

No — clarity says nothing about pathogens. It matters only because turbidity reduces the effectiveness of chemical and UV treatment, which is why pre-filtering murky water is advised before treating it. This page is general guidance; local health authorities are the authority on a specific region.

🔒 This tool runs entirely in your browser. Nothing you enter is uploaded, logged, or stored.